OPINION: Data center giants don't need a PR push. They need to pay their taxes

Posted

After losing at the ballot box and in the court of public opinion in 2026, data center giants are polishing their charm offensive under the impressive banner of the Data Coalition.

Members of the coalition, created in 2025, include a long list of corporate giants such as Google, Microsoft, Amazon, Anthropic and Meta. You don't have to search far to find professionally produced commercials on the coalition's website, which reminds us it's "the voice of the data center industry."

Frankly, I wish them luck. That also goes for Nevada Connects, a coalition nonprofit that extols the virtues of the new technology in the Silver State. Despite the industry's unlimited resources and unlimited love wafting from the White House and Wall Street, I think the Data Coalition and its nonprofit might need plenty of luck in the coming months.

Lately, it's not exactly been smooth sailing on the way to the artificial intelligence (AI) wonderland. Not after Mr. Chips himself, Nvidia co-founder Jensen Huang, horn-dogged his way into a hot-sheet scandal involving a suspected Chinese spy. Huang lost his chairman's position and may have violated federal export control laws if AI chips were diverted to China.

The scent of a felony probably increases Huang's street cred with the Trump administration. With ultimate AI fanboy Donald Trump pulling for him, he's more likely to receive a Presidential Medal of Freedom than stand before a jury.

Meanwhile, data center industry news websites have reported for months that Nvidia likely is the unannounced company that has signed a multibillion-dollar, 16.4-year lease for a hyperscale data center complex under construction by Tract Capital's Fleet Data Centers arm at the Tahoe Reno Industrial Center. Beyond the Huang affair, the multitrillion-dollar company's fortunes should interest Nevada officials.

Trump's 2025 executive order set a welcoming tone that made him an industry darling.

But the public has a much different opinion of data centers, according to several polls. Evidence-backed concerns about power and water consumption and serious environmental impacts appear to have hurt industry cheerleaders in the 2026 campaign.

And they should have. When U.S. hyperscale data centers emit as much greenhouse gas as Denmark, you have a problem on Main Street.

With water always a concern in the driest state in the nation, and a clean and efficient power supply a goal codified in state law, scientists at the Desert Research Institute recently updated their data center impact study. It's well worth your time.

Closer to home, collars continue to tighten at the Public Utilities Commission of Nevada (PUCN) as it attempts to field the industry's increasing efforts to provide its own power generation for its energy-sucking AI facilities. With NV Energy years away from being able to provide full service during the data center gold rush, companies such as Tract's Fleet Data Centers and Switch are moving ahead with plans for "behind-the-meter" methane gas-fired power plants.

Pushback from environmental groups is growing. They lack the big checkbook of the corporate behemoths backing the coalition, but they come armed with pesky facts about the copious amounts of climate-warming carbon dioxide produced by the gas-fired generators. And they're not afraid to shout about how the companies are flouting the state law that sets attainable renewable energy goals.

From city councils to statehouses to Congress, lots of elected officials are hearing the concerns. That anxiety was felt throughout Nevada and half measures such as Gov. Joe Lombardo's (R) September executive order reining in data center concessions now look like political window dressing. The fact is, the public is rightfully skeptical whether the data centers are located in communities, industrial parks or on federal public lands.

By now it should be obvious that data center developers and the enormous corporations that lease them shouldn't receive tax abatements. They create jobs, mostly during construction, and that's a good thing. But they're courting Nevada, contributing hundreds of millions of dollars to political campaigns and don't need the tax breaks they're receiving — an estimated $240 million in sales and use tax abatements over the last four years.

Given the available technology, maybe members of the AI coalition will concoct a plan that wins back the hearts and minds of a majority of skeptical citizens — or at least one that provides political cover for Nevada's elected officials in the days ahead.

They don't need PR professionals or AI magic to accomplish this. They need to stop treating Nevadans like rubes and start paying their taxes.

John L. Smith is an author and longtime columnist. He was born in Henderson and his family's Nevada roots go back to 1865. His stories have appeared in New Lines, Time, Reader's Digest, Rolling Stone, The Daily Beast, Reuters and Desert Companion, among others.

Data Centers, Opinion, Amazon, Google, Joe Lombardo, Meta, Microsoft